The text has been copied to the clipboard
Disability, culture and the U.N. convention.
Journal article

Disability, culture and the U.N. convention.

  • Bickenbach JE Department of Philosophy, Schweizer Paraplegiker Forschung, Nottwil, Switzerland, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario, Canada. bickenbachj@who.int
  • 2009-05-30
Published in:
  • Disability and rehabilitation. - 2009
English Is the universality of human rights, such as those set out in the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, incompatible with therapeutic strategies of respecting cultural differences? I show that universalism is essential to the notion of human rights, as well as the rarely explained, political slogan of 'the rights approach to disability'. Similarly, culture responsiveness is commonly defended by therapists. I argue that the conflict between universalism of rights and cultural sensitivity exist only if these positions are expressed in extreme form: rights absolutism and cultural relativity. If more sensibly spelled out--in the form of progressive realisation of rights and situational sensitivity of difference--there is no conflict at all. Indeed, these more reasonable positions are mutually supportive. I conclude that, given resource and other constraints, the realisation of human rights will always be a matter of political negotiation, and that a social commitment to equality demands that we ensure that only transparent, fully-informed and fully-participatory procedures, respectful of difference [are employed]. These principles should guide us when we have to make hard choices in the implementation of human rights.
Language
  • English
Open access status
closed
Identifiers
Persistent URL
https://sonar.ch/global/documents/278796
Export to…

Statistics

Document views: 70 File downloads: